Will Facebook and Google Pay For News In Canada Next?
A bill forcing the tech giants to pay news publishers is moving forward in Canada, poised to deliver results with little commotion.
Big Technology is a weekly newsletter dedicated to covering the tech world with honest, nuanced reporting. Join the 45,000+ subscribers who tune into Big Technology for tech news without the spin. Here’s an easy way to subscribe:
Canada’s news industry is falling apart. 450 news outlets have closed there since 2008. And more than 60 have shuttered in the past two years. So now, the Canadian government is advancing a bill that would force Facebook and Google to keep the country’s news publishers alive.
Inspired by an Australian law passed last year, the Canadian bill — called C-18, or the Digital News Act — would compel big tech platforms to pay news publishers whose links appear on their services, or face arbitration. The Australian law caused an uproar after Facebook shut down news, hospital, and emergency services pages to hamper it. But the Canadian bill is moving forward swiftly, quietly, and now seems inevitable.
“We should see this pass no later than spring or summer of 2023,” Canadian member of parliament Nathaniel Erskine-Smith told me. “Probably even before that.”
After Facebook’s nuclear reaction to the Australian law — which passed after some watering down — other countries seemed uncertain to pursue similar initiatives. Nick Clegg, Facebook’s president of global affairs, appeared confident in his company’s approach in a recent interview. "I don't think any business would've put up with a proposition where we're just basically being asked to provide an uncapped subsidy to another industry,” he said. “Particularly an industry, in this case, the publishing industry, who derive all the value from us.”
But now, Canada is demonstrating that Australia’s pay-for-news law may be the rule, not the exception. Erskine-Smith said Facebook hasn’t responded as fiercely in Canada as it did in Australia, signaling it accepts what’s coming. “They learned their lesson from really battling in Australia,” he said. “They really just want to make the best of the situation.”
Intriguingly, some of the strongest opposition to the Digital News Act in Canada is coming from news publishers themselves, particularly smaller ones who say the act could entrench larger publications at the expense of upstarts. In a recent open letter, more than 100 Canadian publishers made the case that the bill’s already led to secret backroom deals between the tech platforms and large publishers, and its passage may further separate the industry’s winners and losers.
Google, meanwhile, has criticized the bill, claiming it would break search and potentially lower Canadian journalism standards. Google CEO Sundar Pichai also met with Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau earlier in June, though the meeting was held behind closed doors. The lobbying appears unlikely to change the course of the bill, though. “I don't think this legislation will ultimately be stopped or significantly slowed down from third-party efforts,” Erskine-Smith said.
There is a flaw in relying on tech giants to save your business, namely that they may not remain giants forever. Meta, for instance, has lost more than 50% of its market cap this year. And if forced to share the wealth, it will have less of it to spread around. Erskine-Smith, though optimistic about the bill, acknowledged this weakness. “I don't think this legislation is a silver bullet answer,” he said.
TikTok Is Living In Google's Head Rent Free (Sponsored)
Of all Google’s worries, TikTok seems to be the most prominent. In crucial financial discussions about the company’s business — earnings calls, etc. — ”short-form video” has been the most discussed topic. Google executives regularly bring up Shorts, the company’s TikTok competitor, mentioning its total views (30 billion daily), its creator experience (fantastic), and its ad products (still under development).
This information is accessible within seconds on AlphaSense — effectively a search engine for businesses — along with key stats like Alphabet’s market cap, enterprise value, revenue, employee count, and public sentiment (falling). You find information like this in your area of expertise with a free AlphaSense license, available to all Big Technology Subscribers for the next month. Give it a try here:
What Else I'm Reading
Facebook Groups are copying Discord. Snapchat+ is a thing. Elon stopped tweeting. The Big Tech antitrust battle is heating up in crunch time. FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr wants TikTok out of app stores. China's surveillance tools are trying to predict crime. Hedge funds are shorting Tether. Web3 struggles to name use cases. A look inside the D.C. newsletter, Punchbowl. Moderate Democrats vanish.
Number Of The Week
Number of layoffs in Tesla's autopilot division this week, with more cuts at the company seemingly on the way.
Quote Of The Week
“I have to underscore that we are in serious times here and the headwinds are fierce. We need to execute flawlessly in an environment of slower growth, where teams should not expect vast influxes of new engineers and budgets.”
Facebook chief product officer Chris Cox in an internal memo to the company.
Advertise with Big Technology?
Advertising with Big Technology gets your product, service, or cause in front of the tech world's top decision-makers. To reach 40,000+ plugged-in tech insiders, please reply to this email.
This Week on Big Technology Podcast: The Ethics Of Fintech — With Dan Dolev
Dan Dolev is managing director and senior analyst at Mizuho, where he covers fintech companies Robinhood, SoFi, Affirm, Block, and others. He joins Big Technology Podcast to discuss fintech's ethics and opportunity, explaining who the industry serves, whether it's actually better than the current banking system, and how big it can get. Stay tuned for the second half where we dig into CCoinbase'sbusiness and its recent turbulence.
Thanks again for reading. Please share Big Technology if you like it! Also, click the heart you’d like to be kind like a Canadian.
Questions? Email me by responding to this email, or by writing firstname.lastname@example.org
News tips? Find me on Signal at 516-695-8680